Abstract
This paper interrogates the criminalization of adolescents with a difference of, at most, three years in age who had a consensual sexual relationship vis-a-vis the protection of the best interests of the child and victim. It argues that punishing an 18-, 19-, or 20-year-old who has been in a consensual sexual relationship with a partner who is three years younger (15, 16, 17, respectively) cannot be justified as necessary to protect that young juvenile from the harm and risks of sexual relationship and cause harm to suspect, victim and child born in that relationship. It argues that the close-in-age defence should entail that Rwandan law avoids criminalizing consensual sexual activity between young persons with a gap between them of, at most, three years. To ascertain what should be done to improve the situation, it employs a doctrinal approach and a comparative study to find out how other countries have dealt with the issue at hand
Main Text: View PDF Download PDF
References
LEGAL TEXTS AND REGULATIONS
1. The Constitution of the Republic of Rwanda of 2003 revised in 2015,
2. Official Gazette n° Special of 24/12/2015.
3. law nº 69/2019 of 08/11/2019 amending law nº 68/2018 of 30/08/2018 determining offences and penalties in general, Official Gazette n° Special of 29/11/2019
4. Law nº68/2018 of 30/08/2018 determining offences and penalties in general,
5. Official Gazette no. Special of 27/09/2018.
6. Law no. 27/2001 of 2001 relating to Rights and Protection of the Child against Violence, Official Gazette 25/06/2012.
7. Organic Law n° 01/2012/ol of 02/05/2012 instituting the penal code, Official Gazette nº Special of 14 June 2012.
8. Organic Law no. 31/2007 of 2007 Relating to the abolition of the death penalty 31/2007 of 25 July 2007, Official Gazette nº Special of 25 July 2007
9. Convention on the Rights of the Child adopted and opened for signature, ratification, and accession by General Assembly resolution 44/25 of 20 November 1989 entry into force 2 September 1990.
10. Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Act Amendment Act No. 5 of 2015 (South Africa).
ARTICLE, REPORT, BOOKS, AND PUBLICATIONS
1. Asaph Glosser, Karen Gardiner, Mike Fishman, Statutory Rape: A Guide to State Laws and Reporting Requirements, https://aspe.hhs.gov/system/ files/pdf/75531/report.pdf, accessed on 01/04/2021.
2. ASPE, statutory rape: a guide to state laws and reporting requirements. Sexual intercourse with minors, available at https://aspe.hhs.gov/report/ statutory-rape-guide-state-laws-and-reporting-requirements-summary- current-state-laws/sexual-intercourse-minors, accessed on 05 04/2021.
3. Brittany Logino Smith & Glen A. Kercher, Adolescent Sexual Behavior and the Law 7 (2011), available at http://www.crimevictimsinstitute.org / documents/Adolescent_Behavior_3.1.11.pdf, accessed on 03/04/2021.
4. Campbell collaboration, Campbell Policy Brief No.4 November 2017, the effects of sentencing policy on re-offending a summary of evidence from 12 Campbell systematic reviews, available at https://www. campbellcollaboration.org/media/k2/attachments/Campbell_Policy_ Brief_4_Sentencing_EN.pdf, accessed on 07/04/2021.
5. Child Welfare Information Gateway, determining the best interests of the child, p. 2, available https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/ sessioninfo/2016/interim/160930_fcsc_01d_DetermBestInterestsChild.pdf, accessed on 02/04/2021.
6. Cocca C. Jailbait: The politics of statutory rape laws in the United States. Albany: SUNY Press, 2004.
7. Crockett, Lisa J.; Raffaelli, Marcela; and Moilanen, Kristin L., “Adolescent
8. Sexuality: Behavior and Meaning” (2003). Faculty Publications, Department of Psychology. 245, https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/psychfacpub/245.
1. David NS, Twombly J, State legislators ‘handbook for statutory rape issues, Washington American Bar Association Center on children and law 2000, available at https://ovc.ojp.gov/sites/g/files/xyckuh226/files/publications/ infores/statutoryrape/handbook/statrape.pdf, accessed on 02 /04/2021.
2. Eleanor E. Maccoby, parenting and its effects on children: on reading and misreading behavior genetics, Annu. Rev. Psychol. 2000.51:1-27.
3. Fairgrieve, D., State Liability in Tort: A Comparative Law Study, Oxford University Press, 2003, p.
4. Fischel JJ. Per se or power – age and sexual consent. Yale J Law Feminism 2010; 22(2):279-341.
5. General comment No. 24 (2019) on children’s rights in the child justice system, Committee on the Rights of the Child, CRC/C/GC/24, 18 September 2019.
6. Gevers A, Mathews C, Cupp P, Russell M, Jewkes R. Illegal yet developmentally normative: A descriptive analysis of young, urban adolescents’ dating and sexual behaviour in Cape Town, South Africa. BMC Int Health Hum Rights 2013; 13(1):31. https://doi.org/10.1186/1472- 698X-13-31.
7. Godfrey Dalitso Kangaude and Ann Skelton, (De) Criminalizing Adolescent Sex: A Rights-Based Assessment of Age of Consent Laws in Eastern and Southern Africa, Reproductive Health in Sub-Saharan Africa-Original Research, SAGE Open October-December 2018: 1–12.
8. Graupner H. Sexuality and human rights in Europe. J Homosexuality 2005; 48(3- 4):107-139. https://doi.org/10.1300/J082v48n03_07.
9. Iyakaremye, I., Mukamana, L., Umutoni, J., Paternity denial and consequences on children in a patriarchal society: Situation in consensual couples in Rwanda, Children and Youth Services Review, Volume 118, November 2020.
10. Kern, Jana L. (2013) “Trends in Teen Sex Are Changing, but Are Minnesota’s Romeo and Juliet Laws,” William Mitchell Law Review: Vol. 39: Iss. 5, Article
11. 18Available at: http://open.wmitchell.edu/wmlr/vol39/iss5/18.
12. Koon-Magnin SL. Adolescent sexual activity and statutory rape: A multi- method investigation. MA thesis. Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania State University, 2008.
13. Kristien Michielsen, Pieter Remes, John Rugabo, Ronan Van Rossem & Marleen Temmerman (2014) Rwandan young people’s perceptions on sexuality and relationships: Results from a qualitative study using the ‘mailbox technique’, SAHARA-J: 11:1, 51-60, available at https://www. tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/17290376.2014.927950?needAccess=true, accessed on 30/03/2021.
14. Michelle Oberman, Regulating Consensual Sex with Minors: Defining a Role for Statutory Rape, 1-1-2000, 48 Buffalo Law Review, 48 Buff. L. Rev. 2000.
15. National Commission for Human Rights, GBV especially the defilement increased in Rwanda, available at http://www.cndp. org.rw/index.php?id=187&tx_news_pi1%5Bnews%5D=8&tx_news_ pi1%5Bday%5D=26&tx_news_pi1%5Bmonth%5D=5&tx_news_ pi1%5Byear%5D=2016&cHash=04c6f967dd2b0f583b9c74750e2bdae4, accessed on 30/03/2021.
16. Noy S. Davis & Jennifer Twombly, the handbook for statutory rape issues 2 (2000), available at http://www.mincava.umn.edu /documents/stateleg/ stateleg.pdf.
17. NPPA, National public prosecution authority annual report 2019 - 2020.
18. Nuray Kanbur, Close-in-age exemption laws: focusing on the best interests of children and adolescents, International Journal of Adolescent Medicine and Health, 2019. Available at https://www.degruyter.com/document/ doi/10.1515/ijamh-2018-0143/html, accessed on 04/04/2021.
19. Peters, A. & Schwenke, H., “comparative law beyond post modernism”, International and Comparative Law’ Quarterly [Vol. 49, October 2000] 800, p.831.
20. Raiford JL, Wingood GM, DiClemente RJ. Prevalence, incidence, and predictors of dating violence: A longitudinal study of African American female adolescents, Journal of Women’s Health · July 2007, available at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/6161818_Prevalence_ Incidence_and_Predictors_of_Dating_Violence_A_Longitudinal_Study_of_ African_American_Female_Adolescents/link/54aadbfc0cf2bce6aa1d7433/ download, accessed on 01/04/2021.
21. Raymond R. Corrado, & others, should deterrence be a sentencing principle under the youth criminal justice act? La Revue Du Barreau Canadien, [Vol.85, 2006].
22. Shisana O, Rehle T, Simbayi LC, et al. South African National HIV Prevalence, Incidence, and Behaviour Survey, 2012. Cape Town: HSRC Press, 2014.
23. Sujita Kumar Kar, Ananya Choudhury, and Abhishek Pratap Singh, Understanding normal development of adolescent sexuality: A bumpy ride, J Hum Reprod Sci. 2015 Apr-Jun; 8(2): 70–74.
24. UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC), General comment No. 20 (2016) on the implementation of the rights of the child during adolescence, 6 December 2016, CRC/C/GC/20, available at https://www.refworld.org/ docid/589dad3d4.html [accessed 31 March 2021].
25. UNFPA, criminalization of consensual sexual acts among adolescents in east and southern Africa, available at https://esaro.unfpa.org/sites/default/ files/pub-pdf/technical_brief_criminalization_0.pdf, accessed on 01 April 2021.
26. X, Voice - My rights against sexual abuse, available at https://rwanda. unfpa.org/en/news/my-voice-my-rights-against-sexual-abuse, accessed on 30 March 2021.
27. Z Essack, Unpacking the 2-year age-gap provision in relation to the decriminalisation of underage consensual sex in South Africa, S Afr J Bioethics Law 2018;11(2):85-88. DOI:10.7196/SAJBL.2018.v11i2.657.
CASE LAWS
1. RP 00062/2019/TGI/HYE, Prosecution v Barakagwira Gilbert rendered by the Intermediate Court of Huye on 18/02/2019.
2. RP 00499/2018/TGI/MUS, Prosecution v Ntahorutaba Wellars rendered by the Intermediate Court of Musanze.
3. RS/INCONST/SPEC 00003/2019/SC, Re. Kabasinga, Supreme Court, RLR V.2 - 2020.
4. Teddy Bear Clinic for Abused Children and Another v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Another (CCT 12/13) [2013] ZACC 35; 2013 (12) BCLR 1429 (CC); 2014 (2) SA 168 (CC); 2014 (1) SACR 327 (CC) (3 October 2013), available at http://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ ZACC/2013/35media.pdf, accessed on 03/04/2021.